Home/ Practice Areas/ Personal Injury/ Truck Accidents
Commercial Vehicle Representation

Miami Truck AccidentAttorney

Commercial vehicle collisions involving federal motor carrier regulations, layered insurance, and corporate defendants. Plaintiff and defense representation across South Florida.

!
Critical evidence in truck cases is often destroyed within days. Electronic logging device data, ECM downloads, dashcam footage, and dispatch records can be overwritten under federal retention rules. A spoliation letter to the motor carrier should issue immediately.
📞 Call (305) 774-7000 Request Consultation
★★★★★4.8 / 5.0
100+ Verified Client Reviews
Featured on Google · Avvo · Facebook
35+
Years of Practice
Florida Bar member since 1989
1989
Florida Bar Licensed
University of Miami School of Law
State & Federal
Court Admission
SDFL (1991), MDFL (2001)
Boutique
Practice Model
Direct attorney involvement
Three Layers of Truck Cases

Why Truck Cases Are Different from Car Cases

Commercial truck cases operate under a federal regulatory framework that does not apply to passenger vehicle accidents. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations under 49 C.F.R. impose specific duties on drivers, motor carriers, and equipment owners. Building the case requires understanding all three layers from day one.

01

FMCSR & Driver Compliance

Hours-of-service rules under 49 C.F.R. Part 395, electronic logging devices, drug and alcohol testing, medical certification, and CDL qualification all create compliance duties whose violation can establish liability.

02

Layered Insurance & Liability

Driver, motor carrier, trailer owner, broker, and shipper can all carry separate coverage. Federal MCS-90 endorsements impose minimum financial responsibility from $750,000 to $5 million depending on cargo.

03

Catastrophic Damages

Truck collisions produce serious injuries far more often than passenger vehicle cases. Future medical care, vocational impairment, and life-care planning typically drive the damages analysis.

Three Time-Sensitive Frameworks

Three Deadlines That Define These Cases

Truck accident cases turn on time-sensitive evidence and statutory frameworks. Acting quickly preserves the recovery. The first 30 days, the first 2 years, and the federal preservation duty all matter for different reasons.

30
Days / Evidence Preservation

Spoliation Window

ELD data, ECM downloads, dashcam footage, dispatch records, and driver logs can be overwritten or destroyed under federal retention rules. A spoliation letter must issue immediately.

2
Years / Statute of Limitations

Negligence SOL

For accidents on or after March 24, 2023, the statute of limitations is 2 years under Fla. Stat. § 95.11(4)(a). HB 837 cut this from the prior 4-year period.

49
CFR / Federal Regulations

FMCSR Framework

Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations under 49 C.F.R. govern hours of service, equipment, driver qualification, and operations. Violations can establish negligence per se.

Plaintiff & Defense Representation

Both Sides of Truck Accident Litigation

The firm represents both injured parties pursuing claims and motor carriers, drivers, or insureds defending claims. The strategy is different on each side, but the underlying preparation and discipline is the same.

Pursuing a Claim

Plaintiff Representation

  • Spoliation letters to motor carrier and equipment owners
  • FMCSR violation analysis and negligence per se theories
  • Driver qualification, hours-of-service, and ELD record discovery
  • Vicarious liability and direct negligence claims against carriers
  • Catastrophic damages development including life-care planning
  • Layered policy identification including MCS-90 endorsements
Defending a Claim

Defense Representation

  • Liability and comparative fault defense under HB 837 50% bar
  • FMCSR compliance defense and regulatory record review
  • Damages challenges and pre-existing condition analysis
  • Discovery, IME coordination, and expert defense work
  • Settlement evaluation and offer of judgment strategy
  • Trial defense and post-judgment positioning
Florida and Federal Coverage

Available Coverage Tracks

Truck accident recoveries draw from multiple insurance and liability sources. Identifying every potential defendant and policy at the start of the case preserves the maximum recovery.

Coverage / Recovery
Source
What It Covers
Driver Liability CoverageDirect fault
Driver's policy
The truck driver's individual liability coverage when applicable. Often a smaller policy limit than the motor carrier's. May be primary or excess depending on policy structure.
Motor Carrier LiabilityVicarious / Direct
Carrier's policy
The trucking company's commercial liability coverage. Typically the primary recovery source. Federal minimums under 49 C.F.R. § 387 range from $750,000 to $5 million by cargo type.
MCS-90 EndorsementFederal floor
Carrier's policy
Federal endorsement that creates a financial responsibility floor. Allows recovery directly from the insurer for FMCSA-required minimums even when policy exclusions might otherwise apply.
Trailer Owner LiabilityEquipment
Trailer policy
Separate coverage for the trailer when owned by an entity different from the tractor owner. Common in lease arrangements and intermodal operations.
Broker / Shipper LiabilityNegligent hiring
Broker policy
Negligent hiring or selection theories against freight brokers and shippers when carrier vetting was inadequate. Federal preemption analysis under FAAAA can apply.
Excess / Umbrella CoverageCatastrophic
Multiple sources
Excess and umbrella policies stacked on top of primary coverage. Common in commercial trucking given the catastrophic damages typical in these cases.
UM / UIM CoverageFirst-party
Injured party's policy
The injured person's uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage when applicable. Less common as primary in truck cases given the federal financial responsibility minimums but still relevant.
Comparative Negligence ReductionHB 837
Trial / Settlement
Florida is a modified comparative negligence state. Recovery is reduced by the injured party's percentage of fault. A finding of more than 50% fault bars recovery entirely.

Summary of typical Florida truck accident coverage structure. Not legal advice. Specific availability, policy limits, and recovery amounts depend on the policies involved, the facts of the accident, the cargo type, the carrier's federal authority, the comparative negligence findings, and other factors.

Case Approach

How a Truck Accident Case Gets Built

Truck accident cases require a different approach than passenger vehicle cases from the first phone call. The federal regulatory framework, the layered insurance structure, and the catastrophic damages typical in these matters all demand earlier and more aggressive case development.

Spoliation and evidence preservation. The most important first step in a truck case is sending preservation letters to the motor carrier, the driver, the trailer owner, and any other involved entities. Electronic logging device data, ECM downloads, dashcam footage, dispatch records, driver qualification files, drug and alcohol test records, maintenance logs, and bills of lading can all be overwritten or destroyed under federal retention rules. A 30-day delay can cost the case the most important evidence.

FMCSR violation analysis. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations under 49 C.F.R. impose specific duties on drivers and carriers. Hours-of-service violations under Part 395, drug and alcohol testing failures under Part 382, vehicle maintenance failures under Part 396, and driver qualification deficiencies under Part 391 can all establish negligence per se. The compliance record is often where truck cases are won or lost.

Multiple defendant identification. Truck cases routinely involve more than one potential defendant. The driver, the motor carrier, the trailer owner, the cargo loader, the maintenance contractor, and the broker can all carry potential liability under different theories. Identifying every involved entity early preserves all viable claims and all available coverage.

Damages and life-care planning. Catastrophic injuries are the norm in truck cases, not the exception. Future medical care typically requires expert testimony from a life-care planner. Lost earning capacity often requires vocational expert work. Pain and suffering depends on the medical record and the actual life impact. Building these damages categories properly takes time and preparation.

Litigation readiness. Motor carriers and their insurers defend truck cases aggressively. The cases that resolve on favorable terms are the ones where the plaintiff's preparation makes the carrier's defense strategy untenable. Filing suit, completing discovery, taking the corporate representative deposition, and pushing toward trial often produces the resolution. The settlement that actually compensates the injured person typically comes when the carrier sees the case is being prepared seriously.

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are truck accident cases different from car accident cases?+
Truck cases operate under federal regulation, not just state law. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations under 49 C.F.R. impose specific duties on drivers, motor carriers, and equipment owners. Multiple defendants typically exist: the driver, the carrier, the trailer owner, the cargo loader, and the broker can all be liable under different theories. Damages are catastrophic far more often than in passenger vehicle cases. The investigation, evidence preservation, and case development requirements are different from the first day.
What evidence needs to be preserved immediately after a truck accident?+
Electronic logging device (ELD) data, ECM downloads from the truck, dashcam and forward-facing camera footage, dispatch records, driver qualification files, drug and alcohol test records, hours-of-service logs, vehicle maintenance records, and bills of lading. Federal retention rules allow some of this data to be overwritten within days. A spoliation letter to the motor carrier and any other involved entities should issue immediately to preserve evidence and create the basis for adverse inference instructions if the evidence is later destroyed.
What are the FMCSR and why do they matter?+
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations under Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations govern interstate trucking operations. They cover driver qualification (Part 391), hours of service (Part 395), drug and alcohol testing (Part 382), vehicle maintenance (Part 396), and other operational areas. Violations of FMCSR can establish negligence per se in truck accident cases. The carrier's compliance record is frequently where the case is won or lost.
What is an MCS-90 endorsement?+
The MCS-90 is a federal endorsement required on commercial motor carrier liability policies under 49 C.F.R. Part 387. It creates a financial responsibility floor that allows recovery directly from the insurer for federally-required minimums even when policy exclusions might otherwise apply. Federal financial responsibility minimums range from $750,000 to $5,000,000 depending on cargo type. The MCS-90 frequently provides recovery in cases where the underlying policy would otherwise deny coverage.
Who can be liable in a truck accident case?+
Multiple parties typically carry potential liability in truck cases. The driver may be directly liable for negligent operation. The motor carrier may be vicariously liable for the driver's conduct and directly liable for negligent hiring, training, supervision, or maintenance. The trailer owner may carry separate liability when the trailer is owned by a different entity. The cargo loader, maintenance contractor, and freight broker may all carry liability under different theories. Identifying every potentially responsible party is critical to preserving the recovery.
How long do I have to file a truck accident lawsuit in Florida?+
For accidents occurring on or after March 24, 2023, the statute of limitations is 2 years under Fla. Stat. § 95.11(4)(a). HB 837 cut this from the prior 4-year period. The deadline is strict. Missing the statute of limitations permanently bars the claim. Earlier accidents (before March 24, 2023) may still have the 4-year deadline. Wrongful death claims are 2 years under Fla. Stat. § 95.11(4)(d).
What if the truck driver was an independent contractor?+
Federal motor carrier law makes the carrier responsible for drivers operating under its federal authority regardless of state-law independent contractor status. Under 49 C.F.R. § 376 and the federal logo and lease rules, the carrier whose Department of Transportation number appears on the truck typically bears responsibility. State-law independent contractor defenses commonly fail in interstate trucking cases.
What does it cost to hire a truck accident attorney?+
Truck accident cases are typically handled on contingency for plaintiff representation: the attorney is paid a percentage of the recovery only if there is a recovery. There is no upfront fee. Costs (filing fees, expert fees, deposition costs, accident reconstruction) are typically advanced by the firm and reimbursed at resolution. Defense representation is structured differently, typically on hourly or flat-fee arrangements.
How long does a truck accident case take?+
Truck cases generally take longer than passenger vehicle cases. Cases that resolve through pre-suit demand and negotiation typically take 9 to 18 months. Cases that proceed to litigation typically run 18 to 36 months given the federal regulatory discovery, multiple defendants, and catastrophic damages typical in these matters. Full medical treatment and stabilization is usually the gating factor; case value cannot be evaluated accurately until treatment is complete or stable.
Does the firm represent both plaintiffs and defendants?+
Yes. The firm represents both injured parties pursuing claims and motor carriers, drivers, or insureds facing claims. Each side requires different strategy, but the underlying preparation, document review, and disciplined approach to the case is the same. Conflicts are screened at intake on every matter.
Related Practice Areas

Related Personal Injury Matters

Truck accident cases frequently overlap with other personal injury areas. Each related practice carries its own framework.

Car Accidents

Passenger vehicle collisions involving Florida no-fault PIP, third-party liability, UM/UIM, and the no-fault threshold for non-economic damages.

Learn More →

Motorcycle Accidents

Severe trauma cases involving disputed visibility, contested fault, and significant long-term medical and recovery exposure.

Learn More →

Insurance Disputes

Coverage denials, undervaluation, MCS-90 disputes, and bad faith claims when carriers refuse to pay fair claim value.

Learn More →

Personal Injury

For accident cases that span multiple categories or where the case posture requires broader personal injury strategy.

Learn More →
Speak With Andre

Direct attorney access at (305) 774-7000

Truck accident evidence preservation is time-critical. Cases that resolve well are the ones where counsel was engaged early, spoliation letters issued immediately, and the federal compliance record was developed properly. The first conversation is the right time to start.

📞 Call (305) 774-7000 Request Confidential Consultation
Client Reviews

What Clients Say

Verified Google reviews from clients represented by the firm.